In a case that has sparked national debate, 93-year-old Juanita Fitzgerald was arrested after she refused to leave the Franklin House senior living facility in Eustis, Florida. The incident has drawn widespread attention, highlighting the challenges authorities face when dealing with elderly tenants who resist eviction.
Fitzgerald, who had lived at Franklin House since 2011, reportedly stopped paying rent earlier this year. She allegedly told staff that she believed she would soon die and therefore saw no need to continue making payments. Management at the facility, operated by the nonprofit National Church Residences, stated to local media that they had repeatedly attempted to work with Fitzgerald but that she “refused to pay despite having no valid reason for non-payment.”
In interviews, Fitzgerald countered that she had tried to pay but that the facility would not accept her rent. She also complained of mold in her apartment, though tests ordered by management reportedly came back negative. The conflicting accounts have left many questioning whether the elderly resident’s concerns were taken seriously.
According to authorities, multiple efforts were made to assist Fitzgerald before her arrest. Staff contacted her family in Tennessee, offered to find her alternative housing, and attempted to connect her with social services. Despite these outreach attempts, Fitzgerald repeatedly rejected assistance, insisting she was capable of managing on her own. When presented with an eviction notice, she reportedly told staff, “Unless you carry me out of here, I’m not going anywhere.”
Ultimately, deputies were called to enforce the eviction. Cellphone footage and police body cameras captured the frail nonagenarian being led from the facility, sparking outrage on social media. Many users expressed disbelief at the image of a 93-year-old woman in handcuffs.
Fitzgerald was briefly held at the Lake County Jail, where she gave a defiant interview to reporters. “I don’t want them to help me,” she said. “I don’t need no help. I’ve got all the help I need.”
The incident raises larger questions about how society handles elderly individuals in crisis. While property managers are legally entitled to enforce leases and collect rent, the optics of evicting—and arresting—a 93-year-old woman are troubling to many. Advocates for seniors argue that cases like Fitzgerald’s highlight the need for better coordination between housing providers, social services, and law enforcement to ensure that vulnerable older adults are treated with dignity and compassion.
For now, Fitzgerald’s future remains uncertain. Her story has already prompted calls for policy reviews and renewed discussions about balancing the rights of property owners with the humane treatment of aging residents. As the video of her arrest continues to circulate online, the public is left to grapple with a difficult question: how should authorities handle similar cases without criminalizing old age?
About the Author
